Should Autistic Teenage Girls Have Smartphones? Here's What the Research Actually Says

 The Digital Bridge: What Research Really Tells Us About Smartphones and Teenage Girls with Autism

For parents navigating the complex world of technology and adolescence, one question keeps coming up: Should I let my autistic daughter have a smartphone? Today, we're diving into what peer-reviewed research actually tells us—and where the critical gaps remain.

The Research Exists—But There's a Catch

Here's the truth: Yes, there is legitimate, peer-reviewed research on technology and smartphone use for autistic adolescents. But—and this is a significant but—very few studies specifically focus on teenage girls with autism.

A comprehensive 2021 systematic review examined 32 studies involving 3,026 autistic youth and adults, finding that autistic women participated in only 53% of studies, where they were often a small minority of participants. One-third of studies didn't even report gender at all.

Despite this gap, what researchers have discovered offers valuable insights for parents making decisions today.

What the Science Shows: The Benefits Are Real

1. Enhanced Social Communication

The most striking research comes from a 2023 study that taught texting skills to four autistic children (two girls, two boys). All participants increased appropriate social communication through text messaging, with skills generalizing to texting with parents and siblings, not just peers. Even more impressive? Texting skills transferred to FaceTime verbal conversations, and novel conversation topics increased from 2-7 topics to 10-17 topics.

Why did it work so well? The intervention used visual guidebooks with pictures of text conversations—playing to the visual processing strengths many autistic individuals possess.

2. Greater Control Over Social Interactions

Research shows autistic people experience increased control over social situations through digital communication, with reduced stimuli and greater objectivity. For teenage girls navigating the already complex social landscape of adolescence, this can be transformative.

Benefits include more control over how they talk and engage with others online and a greater sense of calm during interactions. Digital communication allows time to process and formulate responses—something face-to-face conversations rarely permit.

3. Access to Community and Understanding

One of the most powerful findings: smartphones provide access to the autism community and "similar others." Online friendships are often perceived as more secure, with opportunities to express true selves.

A 2024 systematic review on supporting autistic females in high school found that mobile phones can encourage friendships, with friendships and social networks becoming more complex in high school. Technology provides an important support mechanism as social demands increase.

4. Mental Health Benefits

Research documents reduced anxiety and stress in communication, along with decreased loneliness in some cases. The predictability and structure of digital environments can provide comfort that chaotic social situations cannot.

But Let's Talk About the Risks

The research isn't all rosy—and it's important parents understand the potential pitfalls.

Cyberbullying Vulnerability

Autistic people may experience more severe cyberbullying, with vulnerability to deceptive online behavior. The same characteristics that make online communication appealing—directness, literal interpretation—can make autistic teens more vulnerable to manipulation.

Problematic Internet Use

A 2025 meta-analysis of 46 studies with 42,274 participants revealed that people with autism or higher levels of autistic traits showed higher levels of problematic internet use, with an average effect size indicating a meaningful relationship. This problematic use was associated with anxiety and depression.

Interestingly, the same research found a paradox: people with autism or higher levels of autistic traits were less involved on social media platforms compared to their typically developing counterparts. They're online more, but using it differently—often for non-social purposes like gaming or special interest research.

Screen Time and Development

A 2023 systematic review of 46 studies with 562,131 participants found a statistically significant association between screen time and autism spectrum disorder, particularly among studies examining general screen use among children. However, when researchers accounted for publication bias, the findings were no longer statistically significant—suggesting the relationship is complex and requires further investigation.

The Critical Gap: Where Are the Studies on Teenage Girls?

Here's what keeps me up at night as someone who follows this research: we desperately need more studies specifically on autistic teenage girls.

The limited data we have suggests important gender differences:

• Autistic girls were more likely than males to engage in internet browsing, email, or chat
• Autistic boys had greater access to technology but used it differently—more video games, less social communication
• No studies have included transgender autistic youth

Social and emotional experiences of autistic females in high school are key areas to target in ensuring successful education, yet we're making recommendations based largely on research that either combines genders or focuses primarily on boys.

What This Means for Your 13-Year-Old Daughter

Based on available research, here's what parents can reasonably conclude:

Evidence Supports:

1. Smartphones CAN facilitate social communication for autistic adolescents
2. Texting skills can be taught and will generalize to other forms of communication
3. Friendship maintenance across distance becomes possible
4. Anxiety may be reduced in digital versus face-to-face interactions
5. Community access provides identity support and belonging

Protective Factors to Implement:

1. Parent monitoring appears to reduce cyberbullying risk
2. Explicit teaching of online safety and appropriate behavior is essential
3. Balance between online and offline social opportunities remains important
4. Mental health monitoring helps catch problematic use early
5. Privacy education prevents over-disclosure to strangers

The Honest Truth:

We don't yet know:

• What is the optimal amount/type of smartphone use for autistic teenage girls?
• How do benefits and risks differ specifically for girls versus boys?
• What specific online protections do autistic girls need?
• How does smartphone use interact with other supports like therapy or school accommodations?

Moving Forward: A Balanced Approach

The research tells us smartphones aren't inherently good or bad for autistic teenage girls—they're tools that can be used well or poorly. The evidence leans positive when:

1. Parents stay involved without being invasive
2. Skills are explicitly taught rather than assumed
3. Usage is monitored for signs of problematic patterns
4. Online activity complements rather than replaces offline social development
5. The autistic person's voice is centered in decisions about their digital life

As one researcher noted, despite methodological differences in studies, there's sufficient evidence to conclude that technology-mediated interventions can be included in clinical recommendations for managing autism-related social skill difficulties.

The Bottom Line

For parents asking, "Is there research to support smartphone use for my autistic daughter?"—the answer is yes, but with important caveats. The research base is promising but incomplete. We know enough to say smartphones can be beneficial tools for social communication, friendship, and community connection. We also know they require thoughtful implementation, monitoring, and skill-building.

What we're waiting for—what we desperately need—is research that specifically examines autistic teenage girls navigating this digital landscape. Until then, parents must make informed decisions based on extrapolating from mixed-gender studies, using clinical judgment, and most importantly, listening to their daughters' own experiences and needs.

---

Key Research References

Major Studies Cited:

1. Hassrick, E. M., Holmes, L. G., Sosnowy, C., Walton, J., & Carothers, K. (2021). Benefits and risks: A systematic review of information and communication technology use by autistic people. Autism in Adulthood, 3(1), 72-84.

2. Gilder, J., & Charlop, M. H. (2023). Increasing social communication by teaching texting to autistic children. Advances in Neurodevelopmental Disorders, 7, 403-414.

3. Ophir, Y., Rosenberg, H., Tikochinski, R., Dalyot, S., & Lipshits-Braziler, Y. (2023). Screen time and autism spectrum disorder: A systematic review and meta-analysis. JAMA Network Open, 6(12), e2346775.

4. Ayirebi, K., & Thomas, G. (2024). What could be considered as effective support for autistic females in high school? A systematic literature review. Journal of Research in Special Educational Needs, 24(3), 441-453.

5. Muris, P., Otgaar, H., Donkers, F., Ollendick, T. H., & Hosman, L. (2025). Caught in the web of the net? Part I: Meta-analyses of problematic internet use and social media use in (young) people with autism spectrum disorder. Clinical Child and Family Psychology Review.

---

This article is based on peer-reviewed research but is not a substitute for professional medical or psychological advice. Every child is unique, and decisions about technology use should be made in consultation with healthcare providers, educators, and most importantly, in conversation with autistic young people themselves.