Why American Teachers Are Breaking—And What We Can Do About It

The toxic atmosphere in U.S. public education isn't just hurting teachers—it's failing our kids. Here's what the data reveal about this crisis and how we can fix it.

If you've talked to a teacher lately, you've probably heard the exhaustion in their voice. Maybe they've mentioned feeling micromanaged, undervalued, or caught in the crossfire of political battles they never signed up for. It's not just anecdotal—the numbers paint a stark picture of an education system in crisis.

The Happiness Gap: When Schools Can't Heal What Society Breaks

Let's start with a sobering fact: America dropped to 23rd place in the 2024 World Happiness Report—our lowest ranking ever. While that's not strictly about education, the steep decline among young Americans should terrify anyone who cares about schools. We're asking teachers to be therapists, social workers, and academic miracle workers all at once, often without the resources or support to succeed at any of these roles.

The academic data backs up what teachers are experiencing in their classrooms. When we look at 13-year-olds' test scores from 2022-23, reading dropped 4 points and math plummeted 9 points compared to pre-pandemic levels. That's not just a temporary setback—both subjects are performing worse than they were a decade ago.

Think about what this means: the average middle schooler entering high school today has weaker reading and math skills than students from 2013. Teachers are starting from behind and being blamed when students can't catch up.

The Grading Trap: When Accountability Becomes Punishment

Here's the cruel irony of American education: we've created a system obsessed with grading everyone—students, teachers, schools, districts—but we've failed to provide what anyone needs to actually improve.

Our accountability systems love rankings and letter grades. Schools get labeled A through F like report cards, creating pressure that trickles down to every classroom. But pressure without support is just stress. And stress without adequate compensation or respect is a recipe for mass exodus.

The latest international data from PISA 2022 shows this approach isn't working. Math scores fell by record amounts globally, with the U.S. scoring below the international average. We're not just failing to improve—we're moving backward while doubling down on the same failed strategies.

Follow the Money: Why Smart People Leave Teaching

Want to understand why we have a teacher shortage? Look at the paycheck.

In 2023, public school teachers earned about 26-27% less per week than their college-educated peers in other professions. That's the largest "teacher wage penalty" ever recorded. The national average teacher salary was $72,030, with new teachers starting around $44,000-46,000. In some states, starting teachers make less than $40,000.

Let that sink in. We're asking people with four-year degrees (often master's degrees) to accept poverty wages, work nights and weekends grading papers, spend their own money on classroom supplies, and then wonder why they're leaving for jobs at Target that pay better and respect their time off.

2025: When Federal Policy Turns Hostile

If teachers felt unsupported before, 2025 has been a gut punch. The Trump administration has signaled a sharp turn against public education:

The Department of Education is being dismantled. An executive order in March directed the agency to prepare for shutdown, with massive budget cuts already disrupting programs mid-year.

Grants are being canceled wholesale. Dozens of competitive education grants have been axed, including programs that help student-parents afford childcare while pursuing degrees. Districts that planned their budgets around these funds are scrambling to avoid layoffs.

The message is clear: Public schools are something to be bypassed, not strengthened.

Linda McMahon, confirmed as Secretary of Education in March, has aligned the department with these priorities. Meanwhile, policy proposals favor vouchers and charter schools while cutting special education supports and other foundational programs.

For teachers, this feels like betrayal. They're managing post-pandemic recovery with fewer resources while being told their profession isn't worth federal investment.

The Culture War Tax on Learning

As if financial stress and federal abandonment weren't enough, teachers are navigating an unprecedented wave of content restrictions and library challenges. Book removals expanded dramatically in 2023-24, creating a climate of fear about what can be taught or even discussed.

Even teachers who agree with age-appropriate content guidelines find themselves walking on eggshells, unsure what might trigger a complaint or investigation. This chilling effect diverts energy from actual teaching to defensive documentation and self-censorship.

Are We Sabotaging Our Own Schools?

"Sabotage" might sound dramatic, but look at the pattern:

Under-compensate teachers → predictable shortages and turnover
Pile on accountability without support → stress without improvement
Fragment governance and funding → constant instability
Divert public money to private uses → less transparency and equity
Politicize basic educational decisions → energy wasted on performative fights

These aren't accidental side effects—they're predictable outcomes of deliberate policy choices. When you systematically undermine public education's foundation while demanding better results, the only surprise is that any teachers stick around at all.

What Actually Works: Evidence-Based Solutions

The good news? We know what works. Other countries and some U.S. states have proven these strategies:

Pay Teachers Like Professionals

Target that wage penalty directly. States need minimum salary floors tied to local job markets, automatic cost-of-living adjustments, and loan forgiveness for high-need areas. States that made large investments in teacher pay saw immediate improvements in recruitment and retention.

Time Is Currency

Reduce teaching loads and protect planning time. High-performing international systems invest heavily in teacher collaboration time rather than just piling on mandates. More counselors, specialists, and support staff mean teachers can focus on teaching.

Stabilize Federal Support

Instead of scorched-earth policy changes, preserve and expand Title I funding, special education supports, and pandemic recovery programs. Sudden grant cancellations mid-year help no one and hurt students most.

Make Accountability About Building Capacity

Keep transparent reporting, but pair it with quality curriculum, materials, and sustained coaching. Use test data as a dashboard for improvement, not a cudgel for punishment.

Depoliticize the Basics

Create clear, civil processes for addressing concerns about curriculum or library materials. Protect educators' professional judgment within reasonable bounds. Keep classrooms focused on literacy, math, science, and critical thinking—not performative political battles.

The Bottom Line: Teachers Didn't Break This System

Teachers didn't cause America's happiness decline or pandemic learning losses. But they're handed the blame without the pay, time, stability, or trust needed to fix the damage.

The 2025 federal pivot—dismantling the Department of Education, canceling grants mid-year, and prioritizing privatization over public investment—sends a clear message: America doesn't value public education or the professionals who dedicate their lives to it.

You don't fix schools by defunding their supports, demoralizing their workforce, and creating constant political chaos. You fix them by investing in people and backing that investment with adequate time, quality tools, and professional trust.

The choice is ours. We can continue down this path of managed decline, watching talented teachers flee and student outcomes stagnate. Or we can remember that public education—done right—is how democracy renews itself, one classroom at a time.

Our teachers are breaking. Our students deserve better. And the solutions are sitting right there, waiting for us to choose hope over cynicism, investment over divestment, and trust over suspicion.

The question isn't whether we know what works. The question is whether we have the will to do it.

What do you think? Are we sabotaging our own education system, or is this just growing pains in a time of change? Share your thoughts and experiences in the comments below.

“Grading Everyone, Failing Ourselves”: Why U.S. Public Education Feels Toxic—and What the Data Say in 2025

Executive summary

Many U.S. teachers report feeling attacked, micromanaged, and burned out. The data back that up: student outcomes slid after the pandemic and haven’t fully recovered; real teacher pay lags other professions; culture-war policy fights have intensified; and new federal actions under President Donald Trump in 2025 are accelerating a sharp pivot toward defunding and restructuring public education governance. This article pulls together current statistics, policy moves, and structural explanations—and closes with practical, system-level fixes that center teacher well-being and student learning.

1) The “happiness deficit”: teachers and students

U.S. well-being is sliding. The World Happiness Report 2024 placed the United States at 23rd overall—its lowest ranking in the report’s history—and showed steep declines among young Americans. While the report isn’t education-specific, the youth drop is a warning light for schools tasked with shoring up belonging, mental health, and engagement. New York Post
Student learning losses are real and persistent. NAEP Long-Term Trend results for 13-year-olds (2022–23) show reading down 4 points and math down 9 points versus 2019–20; both are also below scores a decade ago. That means the average middle-schooler is entering high school with weaker literacy and numeracy foundations than their predecessors. Nation's Report CardNational Center for Education Statistics
Global benchmarks echo the trend. In PISA 2022, OECD math performance fell by a record amount across countries; the U.S. scored 465 in math (below the OECD average 472), while reading (504) and science (499) were around or above the OECD averages. The unprecedented math slide reflects both pandemic disruptions and pre-existing weaknesses. OECDEducation GPS

Why this matters: Chronic stress + weaker achievement + declining youth well-being create the conditions teachers experience as “toxic.” They’re being asked to fix society-scale problems while feeling less supported and more scrutinized.

2) “Grading the child, teacher, school, district”: incentives that demoralize

U.S. accountability systems emphasize rankings, A–F labels, and test-based sanctions. That can sharpen focus, but the collateral damage is predictable: narrowing curricula; teaching to the test; and heat on teachers without commensurate support, time, or pay. The latest NAEP and PISA data suggest pressure alone isn’t producing better outcomes—and may be pushing educators out when we need them most. Nation's Report CardOECD

3) Follow the money: pay, prestige, and the teacher pipeline

Pay penalty: In 2023, U.S. public-school teachers earned ~26–27% less per week than similarly educated, non-teaching peers—the largest recorded “teacher wage penalty.” That gap fuels attrition and deters entrants. Economic Policy Institute+1CEPR
Recent salary levels: The national average teacher salary in 2023–24 was $72,030; starting salaries averaged ~$44–46k, with huge interstate variation (e.g., < $40k starting pay in some states). Inflation has eroded gains in many districts. National Education Association+1

Why this matters: When professionals accept lower pay, high workload, politicized scrutiny, and dwindling autonomy, burnout rises and recruitment collapses—exactly what district HR leaders report nationwide.

4) 2025 policy shock: a federal turn against public education’s center

While most K–12 funding is state/local, the federal government sets powerful signals. In 2025, the Trump administration has taken a series of moves that many educators interpret as hostile:

Move to dismantle the U.S. Department of Education. An executive order in March directed the Secretary to prepare the Department for shutdown, aligning with a FY 2026 “skinny budget” that steeply cuts non-defense discretionary spending and frames ED for elimination/reduction in force. Even if Congress ultimately blocks full closure, the signal—and interim staffing/funding cuts—creates instability for states and districts that rely on federal programs. Education WeekThe White HouseNASFAA
Secretary of Education: Linda McMahon was sworn in on March 3, 2025 and has since aligned ED actions with the administration’s priorities. U.S. Department of EducationWikipedia
Grant cancellations and program cuts. The administration has canceled dozens of competitive education grants early and, most recently, halted CCAMPIS child-care grants at a number of colleges, with a proposal to eliminate the program in the FY 2026 budget—affecting student-parents’ access to early learning and degree completion. Education WeekThe Washington Post
Aggressive use of funding leverage and compliance actions against higher-ed institutions (e.g., Harvard/Columbia) tied to DEI and discrimination disputes, and new NCES data directives targeting admissions practices post-SFFA v. Harvard. These moves consume agency bandwidth and signal a punitive compliance posture. New York PostU.S. Department of Education
Policy stack favoring privatization. Outside groups and think tanks project expanded vouchers/ESAs, charter growth, and re-prioritization of federal grant competitions toward “choice,” while proposing to repurpose special-education funding levers. Although many particulars will hinge on Congress and courts, the directional push is clear. Center for American Progress

Why teachers feel betrayed: These steps shrink supports (grants, programs, technical assistance), heighten political oversight, and reframe public schools as something to be bypassed rather than strengthened—all while educators are managing post-pandemic recovery.

5) The culture-war tax on classrooms

Beyond Washington, state-level restrictions on curriculum and libraries, plus frequent headline battles, weigh heavily on teacher morale and retention. Book removals and content restrictions expanded markedly in 2023–24, creating ambiguity and fear about what can be taught or read. Even where educators agree on age-appropriateness, the chilling effect is real. (Representative documentation from national free-expression groups and newsrooms shows the breadth of these bans and the uneven enforcement teachers confront.) Vox

6) Is the U.S. “sabotaging” public education?

“Sabotage” is a moral claim; the data show policy choices whose predictable effect is to weaken the public system:

Under-compensation relative to peer professions → shortages and churn. Economic Policy Institute+1
Accountability without capacity → pressure on teachers without parallel investments in materials, time, and student supports. Nation's Report Card
Fragmentation of governance and funding → volatility when federal signals turn punitive and state policies whipsaw. Education WeekNASFAA
Diversion of public dollars to private uses without robust guardrails, often reducing transparency and equity obligations. (Active proposals and budget signals point this direction for 2025–26.) Center for American Progress

Taken together, these choices predictably worsen teacher well-being and student outcomes—hence the widespread perception that America “hates” its teachers.

7) What actually works (evidence-based, system-level moves)

If the aim is to reverse the toxicity and raise learning:

Pay teachers like the professionals they are. Target the wage penalty directly: statewide base-salary floors indexed to local labor markets; automatic cost-of-living adjustments; and loan-forgiveness/tuition remission for shortage fields. States that invested (e.g., recent large raises) climbed salary rankings quickly, improving recruitment. Economic Policy InstituteNational Education Association
Time is currency. Reduce instructional load (fewer preps per day), protect planning time, and staff schools with more counselors, paras, and specialists. Internationally, higher-performing systems invest heavily in teacher collaboration time rather than just adding mandates—one lesson visible in PISA top performers. OECD
Stabilize federal supports, don’t scorch earth. Preserve/expand Title I, IDEA, and pandemic recovery tutoring/extended-time strategies with transparent progress measures; avoid sudden grant cancellations that force districts to lay off staff mid-year. Recent cancellations have already disrupted programming. Education Week
Accountability that builds capacity. Keep transparent reporting, but pair it with coherent curriculum, high-quality materials, and sustained coaching—not test-prep. Use NAEP/PISA as dashboards, not cudgels. Nation's Report CardEducation GPS
De-politicize the basics. Clear, civil policies for library challenges and curriculum choices; protect educator speech within professional standards; keep classrooms focused on literacy, numeracy, science, and civic reasoning rather than performative fights that drain attention. Vox

8) Bottom line

Teachers didn’t cause America’s happiness slump or its pandemic learning losses. But too often, they’re handed the blame without the pay, time, stability, or trust to repair the damage. In 2025, federal actions—executive orders to wind down ED, early grant terminations, program eliminations, and choice-first budgets—have amplified that message. You don’t fix schools by defunding their supports, demoralizing their workforce, and fragmenting governance. You fix them by investing in people and backing the work with time, tools, and trust.

Reading Sage: Your Trusted Reading Community

Monday, September 1, 2025